Not happy with your personal injury lawyer? Maybe your calls aren’t being returned, your case feels stuck, or you no longer feel comfortable with how it’s being handled. At that point, it is reasonable to wonder if you can find someone else to handle your case.
Louisiana law gives you the right to change your lawyer during a personal injury case. If your lawyer is working on a contingency fee, you do not pay two full fees because you changed lawyers. The fee is divided between the lawyers from the same settlement or recovery.
The change itself is straightforward, but there are a few things to know about how the process works and what happens to your case when you switch.
When Should You Think About Changing Your Lawyer?
Not every disagreement means you need a new lawyer. But some problems can make a change worth considering.
You may want to look at your options if:
- Your lawyer rarely returns your calls or emails.
- You cannot get clear answers about your case.
- Your case has been sitting for a long time without a clear reason.
- You disagree about an important decision in your case.
- You no longer trust your lawyer to handle the claim.
- Your lawyer does not explain settlement offers or your options.
Before making a change, consider where your case stands. A lawyer who takes over a case needs time to review the records, understand what has already happened, and prepare for upcoming deadlines.
What Happens To Your Case When You Change Lawyers?
Your case does not start over. The new lawyer takes over the work already done. You can transfer your case file, medical records, accident reports, correspondence, court filings, and other documents to the new attorney. The new lawyer then picks up the case from where the previous lawyer left it.
The timing matters. Court dates and other deadlines do not stop because you are changing lawyers. If your case is already close to trial, the change may also require court approval.
Do You Have To Pay Two Contingency Fees?
No. Louisiana law does not allow you to be charged two full contingency fees for the same personal injury case.
In Saucier v. Hayes Dairy Products, 373 So.2d 102 (La. 1979), the Louisiana Supreme Court set the rule for cases where a client changes lawyers. The contingency fee is based on the recovery. The old and new lawyers divide that fee based on the work each did and the case outcome.
For example, if your agreement calls for a one-third contingency fee and your case settles for $90,000, the total attorney fee is $30,000. Changing lawyers does not make the total fee $60,000.
What About The Costs Already Spent On Your Case?
Attorney fees and case costs are not the same thing. Your current lawyer may have covered filing fees, medical-record charges, court costs, expert fees, or other case expenses.
You still have to account for those costs when the case ends. If you receive a settlement or judgment, the fee agreement and the work already done will determine how those expenses are handled.
Before switching lawyers, ask for a record of the costs already paid. Your new lawyer can then review those expenses along with your existing fee agreement and explain what they mean for your recovery.

What Should You Do Before Switching Lawyers?
Start by talking to the lawyer you are considering hiring. Give them enough information to understand where your case stands before you end the relationship with your current lawyer.
You should also:
- Review your current fee agreement.
- Ask for a copy of your case file if you do not already have one.
- Tell the new lawyer about upcoming court dates or deadlines.
- Ask how they will handle the transfer of your file.
- Make sure you understand how fees and case costs will be handled.
Don’t let the switch cause you to miss a deadline. Louisiana gives most delictual claims arising on or after July 1, 2024, a two-year prescriptive period under Civil Code article 3493.1, but individual cases can have other deadlines that need attention.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I fire my personal injury lawyer without a reason?
Yes. You have the right to end the attorney-client relationship. The reason for the change can affect how the first lawyer is paid.
Will my new lawyer have to start the case from the beginning?
No. Your new lawyer takes over the existing case and reviews the work already completed.
Will changing lawyers delay my case?
It can, especially if the case is close to trial. Your new lawyer needs time to review the file and prepare, but the existing court deadlines continue.
What happens if my old lawyer refuses to give me my file?
Your new lawyer can address the file transfer with the former attorney. A change in representation should not leave you without access to the information you need for your case.
Conclusion
If you have lost confidence in your personal injury lawyer, you do have the option to make a change. The important thing is to understand where your case stands before you do it, especially if there are upcoming deadlines, court dates, or important evidence still being handled.
A new lawyer can review what has already been done, take over the file, and move the claim forward from there.
If you are considering a change, Allan Berger & Associates can review your situation and explain your options. The firm handles personal injury claims on a contingency basis and offers free consultations.
Sources
- Justia – Saucier v. Hayes Dairy Products, Inc., 373 So.2d 102 (La. 1979)
- Louisiana State Legislature – R.S. 37:218, Contingency fee contracts
- Justia – Louisiana Civil Code art. 3493.1, Delictual actions; two-year prescription
